Equality Matters - Blog http://equalitymatters.org This link is for use by RSS-enabled software to retrieve the latest blog posts from Equality Matters en-US Copyright 2014, Media Matters for America This Right-Wing Legal Powerhouse Wants To Make Gay Sex Illegal http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411190001

Few anti-LGBT groups get as much media attention as the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), the right-wing legal organization best known for defending anti-gay business owners who refuse to comply with nondiscrimination laws. But while ADF’s “religious liberty” work generates plenty of headlines, few media outlets have highlighted the most extreme facet of ADF’s legal agenda: criminalizing homosexuality.

ADF is a multimillion dollar Christian legal organization that’s garnered national attention over the past several months thanks to its work defending anti-gay business owners who refuse to serve same-sex couples. It’s been described as “the 800-pound gorilla of the Christian right,” and media outlets are increasingly reporting on the group’s legal efforts. ADF has become a fixture on Fox News, but its involvement in crafting Arizona’s license-to-discriminate law in early 2014 attracted coverage from other networks as well. In October, New York Times columnist Ross Douthat apologized after he spoke at an ADF fundraiser.

But aside from a handful of examples, media outlets have failed to highlight just how extreme ADF’s anti-gay agenda really is. While the group prefers to talk about its “religious liberty” work when in the media spotlight, ADF is actively working to promote and defend anti-sodomy laws that criminalize gay sex.

United States

ADF’s formal support for anti-sodomy laws dates to at least 2003, before the Supreme Court made its landmark decision in Lawrence v. Texas. ADF, which was at the time still known as the Alliance Defense Fund, filed an amicus brief in the case, defending state laws criminalizing gay sex. In its brief, ADF spent nearly 30 pages arguing that gay sex is unhealthy, harmful, and a public-health risk:

[S]ame-sex sodomy is far more effective in spreading STDs than opposite-sex sodomy. Multiple studies have estimated that 40 percent or more of men who practice anal sex acquire STDs. In fact, same-sex sodomy has resulted in the transformation of diseases previously transmitted only through fecally contaminated food and water into sexually causes diseases -- primarily among those who practice same-sex sodomy.

The issue under rational-basis review is not whether Texas should be concerned about opposite-sex sodomy, but whether it is reasonable to believe that same-sex sodomy is a distinct public health problem. It clearly is. [emphasis added]

In 2003, ADF president Alan Sears co-wrote a book titled The Homosexual Agenda: Exposing The Principal Threat to Religious Freedom Today, which warned that eliminating anti-sodomy lawswould lead to the overturning of “laws against pedophilia, sex between close relatives, polygamy, bestiality and all other distortions and violations of God’s plan.”

The Supreme Court disagreed, striking down state bans on gay sex in its Lawrence v. Texas decision. But over a decade later, ADF continues to argue that Lawrence was wrongly decided. In 2011, ADF senior counsel Kevin Theriot criticized then-Secretary of State Hillary Clinton for making the case that “the freedom to engage in homosexual behavior” is a “basic human right.” Theriot also wrote that “claiming a legal right to engage in homosexual behavior comes at the cost of religious freedom.”

But while ADF has largely run out of options for promoting the criminalization of homosexuality in America, the group has taken its anti-sodomy agenda overseas. ADF’s “Foreign Threats” page urges supporters to contribute to ADF’s international efforts to “help stop devastating rulings” against religious freedom like Lawrence, which ADF claims “fabricate[d] legal protection for homosexual sodomy”:

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411190001 Wed, 19 Nov 2014 10:41:57 EST
Meet Cathi Herrod, Arizona’s Extreme Anti-LGBT “Legislative Terrorist” http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411130001

An NBC affiliate in Arizona aired a softball interview with Cathi Herrod, the state’s leading anti-LGBT culture warrior. But while the segment depicted Herrod as a victimized Christian activist, it ignored her history of peddling extreme smears about the LGBT community while fighting against basic legal protections for gays and lesbians.

On November 7, NBC’s Phoenix affiliate Channel 12 News aired an interview with Herrod, the president of the right-wing Center for Arizona Policy (CAP). A promo for the segment described Herrod’s critics as being “hypocritical,” depicting her as a “Christian catching hell”  because of her religious beliefs.

The interview itself, conducted by Channel 12 anchor Lin Sue Cooney, similarly painted Herrod as a victim of “hate” from LGBT activists. The segment, which highlighted Herrod’s Christian faith and upbringing, described her work as “protecting traditional values”:

But Channel 12’s description of Herrod’s work glossed over the extremism that motivates her and her organization’s anti-LGBT work.

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411130001 Thu, 13 Nov 2014 17:02:53 EST
Cleveland.com Falsely Claims Non-Discrimination Law Would Open Women’s Restrooms To Men http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411100001

An article published on Cleveland.com falsely suggested that the city’s proposed gender identity non-discrimination ordinance would be exploited by men who want to sneak into women’s restrooms and showers.

The Cleveland City Council is considering an ordinance that would expand the city’s non-discrimination law to prohibit business from denying transgender people access to restrooms or facilities that correspond with their gender identity.

In a November 6 article published on Cleveland.com, Northeast Ohio Media Group (NEOMG) reporter Leila Atassi claimed the legislation would “open all public restrooms and showers to both sexes”:

In an effort to help transgendered people feel more comfortable using public restrooms, Cleveland City Council is considering an ordinance that would require businesses to make their restrooms, showers and locker rooms available to both sexes.

And barring one gender from using a facility designated for the other would be a crime punishable by a $1,000 fine.

The measure, which will be discussed at a Workforce and Community Benefits Committee meeting Wednesday, is part of a package of ordinances that update the city's existing anti-discrimination laws to include the transgender community. (Read the legislation in the document viewer below.)

Councilmen Joe Cimperman and Matt Zone, who sponsored the legislation dealing with the "public accommodations" of private businesses, said in interviews Thursday that the measure is designed to give transgender people the power to use whichever restroom aligns with their gender identity.

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411100001 Mon, 10 Nov 2014 16:53:51 EST
Anti-LGBT Conservatives Are Rallying In <em>Defense</em> Of Election Fraud In Houston http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411030001

Texas conservatives failed to submit enough valid signatures to put Houston’s city-wide non-discrimination ordinance up for a public vote in November. Now those conservatives, led by Fox News, are pressuring the city to accept signatures determined to be improperly collected or otherwise irregular in order to “let the people vote” to repeal the measure.

In August, opponents of Houston’s recently enacted Equal Rights Ordinance (HERO) reportedly submitted more than the seventeen thousand signatures needed to qualify put the measure on the November ballot. However, upon review of the petition under the City Charter, City Attorney David Feldman determined that thousands of the signatures failed to meet the legal requirements set by local and state law for a voter referendum. As explained by the Mayor’s office:

“The Charter requirements are in place to ensure a fair and legal process, absent of fraud,” said City Attorney David Feldman.  “In this instance, there are too many documents with irregularities and problems to overlook.  The petition is simply invalid.  There is no other conclusion.”


“I fully expect the petitioners will want to fight this decision at the courthouse,” said Mayor Annise Parker.  “I am confident the courts will agree that the rules set out in our Charter and state law to protect the integrity of the process should be followed and that the results of our review will be upheld.  The judicial review will provide additional assurance to the voters that the process has been fair.”

On November 2, thousands of conservatives met in Houston at the “I Stand Sunday” rally to demand that the city government allow for a public vote on the ordinance, despite the failure of the repeal petition. The event, which was hosted by the anti-gay hate group Family Research Council (FRC), was widely promoted by Fox News and featured speeches from Fox’s Todd Starnes and Mike Huckabee.

At the rally, speakers demanded that the city of Houston “let the people vote” on the ordinance, accusing openly gay Mayor Annise Parker of violating the religious liberty of HERO’s opponents by refusing to count their improperly collected signatures:

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201411030001 Mon, 03 Nov 2014 16:37:21 EST
Fox News Is Trying To Kill Houston&rsquo;s Equal Rights Ordinance http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410300001

Fox News helped turn a bogus story about the subpoenaing of a handful of Houston pastors into a national rallying cry for religious liberty. Now the network is helping promote an event that will pit some of the country’s most extreme anti-LGBT voices against the city’s non-discrimination ordinance.

In May, the city of Houston made history by enacting the Houston Equal Rights Ordinance (HERO), a measure which prohibits discrimination in housing, employment, and public accommodations on the basis of race, gender, sexual orientation, gender identity, and several other categories. The ordinance was championed by the city’s first openly gay mayor, Democrat Annise Parker.

Opponents of HERO – led by the Houston Area Pastors Council – responded by launching an effort to put a repeal of the ordinance on the ballot in November. Their campaign peddled the myth that HERO would allow men and sexual predators to enter women’s restrooms – a myth that was widely circulated by local media. Though opponents submitted the required number of signatures to put HERO on the ballot, City Attorney Dave Feldman determined that many of the signatures were collected improperly and the city announced that not enough valid signatures had been collected to put HERO on the ballot.

Opponents quickly filed a lawsuit to have the signatures reviewed, prompting the city to respond by subpoenaing five local pastors for a broad range of documents – including sermons and personal communications – related to their opposition to HERO.

On October 14, Fox News reporter and serial misinformer Todd Starnes broke the news of the subpoenas, misleadingly characterizing them as an “attempt to deconstruct religious liberty” and describing HERO as a “bathroom bill. Starnes’ report relied heavily on spin from the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), the extreme right-wing legal group representing the pastors in their effort to quash the subpoenas. ADF attorney Christina Holcomb called the subpoenas “an inquisition designed to stifle any critique of [the city’s] actions.”

Before long, Starnes’ report made the jump to Fox News’ airwaves. On October 15, Starnes appeared on The Kelly File to discuss the story, describing HERO as a measure that would let “men who identify as women” to use women’s restrooms:

Following Starnes’ appearance was followed by a barrage of misleading segments about the story, all of which depicted the subpoenas as an attack on religious liberty. Several Fox personalities incorrectly described the subpoenas as part of the enforcement of HERO, suggesting that the ordinance might criminalize anti-gay speech. Many others repeated Starnes’ lie that HERO would allow men to use women’s restrooms. In the four days following Starnes’ initial report, Fox had spent nearly half an hour of airtime peddling falsehoods abut Houston’s subpoenas*.

Fox’s panicked coverage was grossly misleading and left out crucial details about the anti-HERO lawsuit. But it worked perfectly as a right-wing horror story about Christians being victimized by a city’s attempt to protect LGBT people.

Soon, Houston had become – as one Fox anchor put it - “ground zero for religious liberty.” Major conservative media outlets quickly regurgitated Starnes’ and ADF’s victimization spin. Conservative groups – led by the notorious anti-gay hate group the Family Research Council (FRC) – began organizing “I Stand Sunday,” a November 2 rally in Houston to support the pastors who had been “unduly intimidated by the city’s Mayor.”

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410300001 Thu, 30 Oct 2014 14:54:10 EST
Anti-Gay Columnist MacKinnon Out At The<em> Tampa Tribune</em> http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410280002

Just days after suggesting that some southern states should secede from the U.S. to form a new country that is based on "traditional values" and less tolerant of the LGBT community, columnist Douglas MacKinnon has left his job at the Tampa Tribune, according to the paper's publisher. 

MacKinnon, a former aide to Ronald Reagan, recently published The Secessionist States of America: The Blueprint for Creating a Traditional Values Country...Now. According to Right Wing Watch, during a recent interview with conservative radio host Janet Mefferd promoting the book, MacKinnon "specifically cited advances in gay rights as a reason for Southern states to leave the U.S. and create a new country." His proposal -- including floating "Reagan" as an "interim name" for the new country -- received widespread ridicule

Citing unnamed sources, Tampa outlet Creative Loafing reported Monday that MacKinnon had been fired, speculating that it was "because of the embarrassment to the paper." Tampa Tribune publisher Brian Burns confirmed to Media Matters today that MacKinnon was indeed leaving the paper, but declined to give a reason. According to Burns, "at this point, no he is not employed." 

Asked by Media Matters to clarify if MacKinnon had been fired or quit, Burns said, "I really can't comment on it, it's a personnel issue so we gotta keep that internal."

MacKinnon could not be reached for comment Tuesday.

MacKinnon's secession proposal follows an incident in August when the columnist sparked controversy for a piece that claimed the Walt Disney Company had a "pro-gay agenda" and was trying to "indoctrinate" children.

The Tribune later pulled that column from its website.


Tampa Tribune Pulls "Repugnant" Anti-Gay Column

Tampa Tribune Columnist: Disney Is “Indoctrinating” Children With A “Pro-Gay Agenda”

Joe Strupp http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410280002 Tue, 28 Oct 2014 14:12:45 EST
Watch This ADF Attorney Call Matthew Shepard&rsquo;s Murder A Hate Crime Hoax http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410280001

An attorney for anti-LGBT extremist group the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) peddled the myth that the story of Matthew Shepard’s brutal anti-gay murder was fabricated in order to advance the “homosexual agenda.”

On October 27, the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission held its annual national conference in Nashville, Tennessee. The conference, “The Gospel, Homosexuality, and the Future of Marriage,” featured a presentation led by attorneys from the notoriously anti-LGBT legal group ADF.

During the presentation, ADF attorney Erik Stanley told the audience that “the end game of the homosexual legal agenda is unfettered sexual liberty and the silencing of all dissent.” After lamenting the fact that television shows like Modern Family had “normalized homosexual behavior,” Stanley went on to claim that the “narrative” of Matthew Shepard’s brutal murder had been “debunked”: 

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410280001 Tue, 28 Oct 2014 10:23:57 EST
<em>The Guardian&nbsp;</em>Promotes Discredited, Debunked Book About Matthew Shepard&rsquo;s Murder http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410270001

The Guardian helped peddle a thoroughly discredited book alleging that Matthew Shepard was murdered in a drug-related incident, even though lawyers and investigators involved in the case have denounced the book as “fictional.”

On October 25, The Guardian published an article by columnist Julie Bindel titled “The truth behind America’s most famous gay-hate murder.” The report focuses on the widely discredited 2013 book The Book of Matt, in which author Stephen Jimenez attempts to make the case that Matthew Shepard’s brutal murder in 1998 was drug-related and not, as it is widely believed, motivated by anti-gay hate.

The book has been criticized for relying on shoddy sources and omitting key facts about the case, prompting the Matthew Shepard Foundation to condemn the book for being based on rumors and innuendo.

Jimenez’s book has been described as “fictional” by the lead detective in the case. People familiar with the murder – including one of the killer’s appellate attorneysAlbany County Sheriff Dave O'Malley, and Albany County Undersheriff Robert Debree – have condemned the book as factually challenged.

But Bindel didn’t include those criticisms in her piece. Instead, she portrayed Jimenez as a victim of gay activists’ blind desire to hide the truth about Shepard’s murder:

Jimenez has faced a barrage of criticism since the publication of his book and has had readings to promote the book boycotted. Jimenez claims, however, that many of his critics have not actually read it.


“People object to the idea of the book, rather than what is in the book,” says Jimenez. “The anger directed at me has been pretty extreme.”


[T]he mystery remains – not so much why Matthew died, but why the gay community, after almost five decades of campaigning for equal rights, relies so fundamentally on the image of the perfect martyr to represent the cause.

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410270001 Mon, 27 Oct 2014 15:51:59 EST
What You Need To Know About The For-Profit Idaho Chapel Being &ldquo;Forced&rdquo; To Perform A Gay Wedding http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410230001

Conservative media outlets are promoting the cause of an Idaho wedding chapel suing so it can deny services to gay couples, inaccurately portraying the chapel as a religious institution rather than as a for-profit business.

On October 17, the anti-gay legal group Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) filed a lawsuit against the city of Coeur d’Alene, Idaho, on behalf of the chapel, which is called the Hitching Post. The lawsuit alleges that the city’s non-discrimination ordinance would force owners Donald and Evelyn Knapp to violate their religious beliefs by performing same-sex weddings, despite the fact they had previously offered to officiate non-religious ceremonies without complaint.

ADF is using the lawsuit to revive the right-wing horror story that churches and clergy members will be forced to perform gay weddings. ADF senior legal counsel Jeremy Tedesco stated in a news release, “Many have denied that pastors would ever be forced to perform ceremonies that are completely at odds with their faith, but that’s what is happening here.”

Right-wing media, led by Fox News reporter Todd Starnes, have echoed ADF’s spin. Starnes was the first to misrepresent the case, writing:

What in heaven’s name is happening to our country, folks? I was under the assumption that churches and pastors would not be impacted by same-sex marriage.

That talking point was echoed by The Daily SignalHuman Events, and Red State, as well as several Fox News segments.

But conservative reports about the Hitching Post lawsuit have omitted important facts about the case:

http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410230001 Thu, 23 Oct 2014 13:49:55 EST
<em>New York Times</em> Columnist Apologizes For Attending Fundraiser For Anti-Gay Legal Group http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410220001

New York Times columnist Ross Douthat apologized for appearing at a fundraising event for Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), an extreme anti-gay legal group working to criminalize homosexuality.

On October 16, Douthat spoke at "The Price of Citizenship: Losing Religious Freedom in America," an event held by ADF and aimed at drawing attention to a number of popular right-wing horror stories about the threat LGBT equality poses to religious liberty. Douthat spoke alongside radio host Hugh Hewitt and the Benham brothers, who are notorious for their history of extreme anti-gay, anti-choice, and anti-Muslim rhetoric. The event ended with explicit solicitations for donations to support ADF's legal work.

As Media Matters noted, ADF is one of the most extreme anti-gay legal groups in the country, fighting against even basic legal protections for LGBT people and working internationally to repress LGBT human rights, including supporting Belize's draconian law criminalizing gay sex.

On Wednesday, Douthat explained that he did not know ADF's event was a fundraiser and said he plans to decline the honorarium he received from the event.

"I was not aware in advance that this event was a fundraiser and had I known, I would not have agreed to participate," he said in a statement issued to Media Matters through the Times Wednesday. "I was invited by an events organizing group, not by ADF directly. I understood this to be a public conversation about religious liberty. This is my fault for not doing my due diligence, and I will be declining the honorarium."

Carlos Maza & Joe Strupp http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410220001 Wed, 22 Oct 2014 14:05:19 EST
A <em>New York Times</em> Columnist Spoke At A Fundraiser For A Group Working To Criminalize Gay Sex http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410210001

New York Times columnist Ross Douthat spoke at a fundraising event for the Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF), a right-wing legal group that works to defend anti-LGBT discrimination and supported the criminalization of homosexuality.

On October 16, ADF held an event titled “The Price of Citizenship: Losing Religious Freedom in America” in Denton, Texas. The event, which focused primarily on highlighting the alleged tension between LGBT equality and religious liberty, featured a conversation between radio show host Hugh Hewitt and Douthat.

The event also featured an appearance from the Benham brothers, the right-wing activists who lost their HGTV reality show because of their history of extreme anti-gay, anti-choice, and anti-Muslim rhetoric:

The event touched on a number of popular right-wing horror stories about LGBT equality, from the plight of anti-gay bakers and florists, to the outrage over the recent subpoenaing of several Houston pastors. David Benham, who has previously warned that the gay “agenda” is “attacking the nation,” urged the audience to take “dominion” of the media and legal system back from the “sexual anarchy agenda”:

DAVID BENHAM: Unfortunately, the church, now that we have the keys to authority that Christ gives the Christian church, we give that dominion back through our silence. And so what we see now is the struggle for dominion. And one of the ways that we’ve lost dominion is because Christians, unfortunately, don’t believe in the sovereignty of God. God is sovereign over all things. The Bible says in Psalm 24 “the Earth is the Lord’s and everything in it,” including government, entertainment, media, education, the legal system, everything. My finances, my sexuality, everything is under God. … Does this agenda, this sexual anarchy agenda, does it want dominion? Take a look. Has it got dominion in government? Has it got dominion in entertainment? Has it got dominion, I mean, you name it, in the marketplace? Yes. Absolutely it does. How does God get dominion back? ... The government exists for the punishment of evildoers and for the reward of those who do good. The problem is, is when we switch good and evil and evil and good. There’s only one institution that can fight that dominion battle, and that’s the church. [emphasis added]

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410210001 Tue, 21 Oct 2014 09:53:06 EST
Another Fox News Lie About The Subpoenas Of Houston&rsquo;s Anti-Gay Pastors http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410170002

Fox News peddled a new lie about Houston, TX’s LGBT non-discrimination ordinance, blaming the measure for unrelated subpoenas issued against a number of local anti-gay pastors.

On October 10, the city of Houston subpoenaed documents related its recently-passed Equal Rights Ordinance (HERO) from five local pastors who had opposed the law. The subpoenas are part of the discovery phase of a lawsuit filed by opponents of the ordinance who allege that the city wrongly disqualified petition signatures supporting a repeal referendum. Conservative media outlets, led by Fox News, have inaccurately accused the city of attempting to “harass” and “bully” the anti-gay pastors, depicting the subpoenas as an assault on religious liberty.

During the October 17 edition of Fox & Friends, co-host Anna Kooiman falsely stated that the subpoenas were actually “part” of the non-discrimination ordinance:

KOOIMAN: The city now being accused of ordering its pastors to “show us your sermons” or be held in contempt of court. The move, part of an ordinance aimed at ending discrimination against the LGBT community but critics say it actually stifles religious liberty. [emphasis added]

Kooiman’s lie was echoed during the same day’s edition of Fox News’ Outnumbered. Fox News contributor Kirsten Powers attacked the ordinance, accusing the measure of trying to “legislate speech”:

POWERS: This is such a blatant violation of the First Amendment. It's so chilling. And these anti-discrimination statutes, the way that they're being implemented is very scary and very chilling as well because it's basically, they're deciding what your views are supposed to be on certain things and they're now trying to legislate it. And they're trying to legislate speech. [emphasis added]

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410170002 Fri, 17 Oct 2014 13:33:42 EST
Purple Penguins: How Conservative Media Make It Harder For Schools To Protect Transgender Youth http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410170001  

The conservative media's meltdown over a Nebraska school district's effort to train teachers about gender diversity demonstrates how conservative misinformation threatens even basic efforts to protect transgender and gender non-conforming students.

In late September, administrators from the Lincoln Public Schools (LPS) district in Nebraska began providing teachers with informational materials aimed at better equipping them to accommodate and protect transgender and gender non-conforming students. The materials included handouts from the group Gender Spectrum, which works to help develop "a gender sensitive and inclusive environment for all children and teens."

One of those handouts, "12 easy steps on the way to gender inclusiveness," listed recommendations to help teachers make their classrooms more gender-inclusive, including asking teachers to stop gender-based bullying and avoid the use of gender-specific terms like "ladies and gentlemen." Instead, Gender Spectrum recommended teachers use terms like "readers," "campers," or classroom nicknames like "purple penguins."

The school district's distribution of Gender Spectrum's materials sparked controversy when the conservative group Nebraska Watchdog published a report on the handout on October 2. The report was picked up by National Review Online and The Daily Caller before eventually making the jump to Fox News. The network ran multiple segments falsely accusing LPS of "banning" terms like "boys and girls" as part of a "political agenda."

In an interview with Equality Matters, Gender Spectrum's Director of Education Joel Baum criticized the "disingenuous" reporting on his organization's training materials. "They're sharing information about work that's occurring in a school and not being accurate about ... the overall purpose of the work," he said. "[B]y taking various things out of context - like "purple penguins" - they completely trivialize something that's really, really important and misrepresent our work."

Fox's misleading coverage of Gender Spectrum's handouts eventually prompted LPS Superintendent Steve Joel to call a press conference to dispel the network's misinformation. Joel criticized conservative media outlets for peddling falsehoods about the educational materials, calling it "regrettable" and "truly unfortunate" that the school was forced to waste time and resources responding to calls and questions about the handouts.

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410170001 Fri, 17 Oct 2014 09:36:35 EST
No, The City Of Houston Isn&rsquo;t Bullying Anti-Gay Pastors &ndash; This Is Basic Lawyering http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410160001

Conservative media outlets, led by Fox News, are attacking the city of Houston for subpoenaing a number of local pastors who were part of the right-wing opposition to the city’s LGBT non-discrimination ordinance that is suing the city now that the anti-discrimination law is in effect. But their claims that religious liberty should keep the pastors’ public addresses secret ignores the fact that subpoenas of parties relevant to a lawsuit are a typical part of the legal discovery process.

Conservative media reacted with outrage to reports that the city of Houston had subpoenaed five local pastors requesting a variety of documents related to their involvement in the legal battle over the city’s recently passed Equal Rights Ordinance (HERO), which prohibits discrimination against LGBT residents. The subpoenas included a request for “all speeches, presentations, or sermons related to HERO, the Petition, Mayor Annise Parker, homosexuality, or gender identity.”

On October 13, the anti-gay legal group Alliance Defending Freedom (ADF) filed a motion to quash the subpoenas, calling them “overbroad” and “unduly burdensome.” The motion was reported by Fox News’ Todd Starnes, who accused the city of Houston of trying to “silence American pastors” and “deconstruct religious liberty”:

I predicted that the government would one day try to silence American pastors. I warned that under the guise of “tolerance and diversity” elected officials would attempt to deconstruct religious liberty. 

Sadly, that day arrived sooner than even I expected.


Now is the time for pastors and people of faith to take a stand.  We must rise up and reject this despicable strong-arm attack on religious liberty. We cannot allow ministers to be intimidated by government thugs.

Starnes’ apoplectic report triggered a wave of conservative misinformation about the subpoenas, with commentators accusing the city government of engaging in unconstitutional bullying and anti-religious harassment. Fox News has covered the story in similarly misleading segments on Fox & Friends, Hannity, and The Kelly File:

But the facts of the case – and normal legal procedure -- don’t support right-wing claims of religious persecution:

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410160001 Thu, 16 Oct 2014 10:32:26 EST
Fox News Ignores &ldquo;Stunning&rdquo; Vatican Document Welcoming Gays http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410150001

Fox News entirely ignored a Vatican report described as "stunning" by religious leaders which suggested that the Catholic Church should welcome and appreciate gay people, despite the network’s track record of using religion as an excuse for discriminating against gays and lesbians.  

On October 13, an assembly of Roman Catholic bishops at the Vatican released a preliminary document suggesting that the church should be more welcoming and accepting of gay people, stating that gay people have “gifts and qualities to offer the Christian community”:

Homosexuals have gifts and qualities to offer to the Christian community. Are we capable of welcoming these people, guaranteeing to them a fraternal space in our communities? Often they wish to encounter a church that offers them a welcoming home. Are our communities capable of providing that, accepting and valuing their sexual orientation, without compromising Catholic doctrine on the family and matrimony?

The document has been described as a “pastoral earthquake” and a “stunning” change in tone for the Catholic Church on the issue of homosexuality. Both CNN and MSNBC devoted significant airtime in the 48 hours following the document’s release, discussing its implications for the Catholic Church, the legacy of Pope Francis, and even domestic GOP politics.

But on Fox News, the “pastoral earthquake” went completely unnoticed. According to an Equality Matters analysis, Fox News didn’t report on the story once on either October 13 or 14:

Carlos Maza http://equalitymatters.org/blog/201410150001 Wed, 15 Oct 2014 15:35:22 EST